Sailor Rose Dust wrote:
Then discuss the reviews, not bash the guy who wrote them.
We aren't bashing him, just discussing the reviewer and his reviews.
|
| |
|
Welcome to Knothole Village! Take a visit here under the shade of the Great Forest and chill for a while. This forum is open for all discussion on absolutely ANYTHING concerning the Archie Sonic Comics, or their cartoon origins in Sonic SatAM and AoStH. SU discussion is also okay here. Consider this place a hub for all fans that wish to discuss, complain, or praise recent goings on. Have fun! :) |
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Bsonic10 |
|||
Sailor Rose Dust wrote: We aren't bashing him, just discussing the reviewer and his reviews. |
|||
kaze the chao |
|||
|
All right, I think I've seen enough to sort of gather what's going on here.
I was asked to look over this thread, and I've gotta say, there seems to be less actual discussion and some posts seem close to borderline bashing. If you're going to disagree with him, then say you disagree and move on. I do understand that everyone is entitled to their opinions, but don't say things like he's "out of touch with Sonic" and stuff like that. You know who you are. I'll be keeping an eye on this for a while. Any bashing, and I mean *any* or stuff close to it, and warnings will be given out. |
|||
DC |
|||
|
Dan's 197 review, he liked Sally's part of the story,which I did too.
http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/S197.txt Also Sonic X 40 http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/SX40.txt
Last Edited By: DC
03/23/2009 6:15 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Psxphile |
|||
|
Oops, spoiled meself.
Warning to everyone: If you haven't played (or watched, as Dan did) Sonic and the Black Knight to the end, don't read the second half of his analysis of #197. Huge spoilers, there. Sega 02: "SONIC TEAM. The Sonic Team development studio was established to execute the wishes of Sega." Sega 03: "It was intended to enact the business strategy we had created." Sega 05: "However, it appears to have become dominated by a single, zealous individual." Sega 04: "Yes it has. We must take it back into our own dominion." Sega 01: "It is time. We must restore SONIC TEAM and the Sonic series to their proper role." |
|||
Bsonic10 |
|||
|
I appreciate the fact that he actually did a bit of research this time around. I think he might be a tad biased for the Sally story, but that's just what
I think. It kind of felt like he only glazed over the last bit of #197 with Snively though, either that or he just didn't really comment on it/left things
out.
I don't necessarily agree with all of his opinions on the SX comic, but he's free to them. |
|||
DC |
|||
|
Dan's review of issue #199:
http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/S199.txt |
|||
tornadot |
|||
|
Only heart I saw in this issue (Other than the Knux and Julie scene) was the huge cloud of hearts buzzing around Amy's head.
|
|||
tiggerkiddo |
|||
|
|
|||
DC |
|||
|
|
|||
Solo the bringer of Chaos |
Su reviews | ||
|
Nobody seemed to notice these reviews
http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/SU4.txt http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/SU3.txt |
|||
DC |
|||
|
Dan's Sonic Universe #5 review, he loved it. I do agree, I really want to see the Freedom Fighters end up happy, together, and enjoying their families,
even if it does end up canceling the comic book.
http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/SU5.txt |
|||
Toby Barrett |
|||
|
That seems rather selfish.
|
|||
gammarallyson |
|||
|
How So?
Quote: |
|||
Psxphile |
|||
|
Well, for one... Ian and the artists would be out of work.
Also... some people prefer a constant state of conflict to the proverbial 'happy ending' and would like the book to continue indefinitely. You could say that our thirst for more Sonic "Adventures" necessitates the need for more battles, which of course leads to more in-book suffering. A vicious 'Sonic comic cycle', if you will. Sega 02: "SONIC TEAM. The Sonic Team development studio was established to execute the wishes of Sega." Sega 03: "It was intended to enact the business strategy we had created." Sega 05: "However, it appears to have become dominated by a single, zealous individual." Sega 04: "Yes it has. We must take it back into our own dominion." Sega 01: "It is time. We must restore SONIC TEAM and the Sonic series to their proper role." |
|||
DC |
|||
Toby Barrett wrote: Maybe so, one could also say that the other side is selfish too though, wanting things to continue for their own needs. Also, it seems wrong and cold-hearted, taking pleasure in wanting to see the heroes continuely suffer and not wanting them to end up happy. I don't think my point of view is totally selfish, there is an element of unselfishness, because it comes from caring about the characters and it would cost me something I do enjoy, although the way things are makes it difficult to enjoy the comic at times.
Last Edited By: DC
08/03/2009 7:15 AM.
Edited 3 times.
|
|||
Bsonic10 |
|||
|
Who says the ending will be a happy one? Assuming the chord isn't pulled immediately, and Ian or whoever can actually plan the ending, the ending might not
be that happy or exactly what you want. More than likely, if the comic ended you wouldn't see an ending you liked, or really an ending at all.
And just because people enjoy the comic doesn't mean that they "take pleasure" in watching characters "continually suffer", that's just silly. If the comic goes on, you can learn more about and enjoy the characters more, while watching them grow from their experiences.
Last Edited By: Bsonic10
08/03/2009 11:25 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
DC |
|||
|
Since no one has posted it yet, here is Dan's reivew of #202.
http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/S202.txt Playing catch up here, Dan's Review of #205. http://www.andrews.edu/~drazen/S205.txt
Last Edited By: DC
11/09/2009 7:00 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||