The Girls of the Archie Comics : WHAT ARE THEIR FLAWS/FAULTS?

RSS
Email

0 Kudo

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Author

Comment

Harry Megamix

The Girls of the Archie Comics : WHAT ARE THEIR FLAWS/FAULTS?

Lead

[-]

Posts: 4

(11/11/2008 11:45 PM)

This is for people who know ANY of these characters well.

Princess Sally

Bunny Rabbot

Mina the Mongoose

Hershey the Cat

....Are there any other girls that I'm forgetting to mention?

The topic is: What stops each of these girls from being a Mary-Sue? What are their flaws or faults? Be sure to back up your answers with dialogues or actions from these girls.

Last Edited By: Harry Megamix 11/12/2008 12:33 AM. Edited 4 times.

Craig Bayfield

[-]

Posts: 4135

(11/11/2008 11:52 PM)

Kyon/John Smith Shipper

Is this a college assignment you're asking us to write for you?

I'm starting to think all of these Mary-Sue/Gary-Stu topics and the "How do you write a three dimensional character" thing under different usernames feels more like market research fact gathering than discussion. What are your thoughts and opinions on these matters?

Harry Megamix

[-]

Posts: 5

(11/12/2008 12:13 AM)

Craig Bayfield wrote:

Is this a college assignment you're asking us to write for you?

I'm starting to think all of these Mary-Sue/Gary-Stu topics and the "How do you write a three dimensional character" thing under different usernames feels more like market research fact gathering than discussion. What are your thoughts and opinions on these matters?

Craig, you're not very good at warning us when you're getting off-topic.

The only thing in your reply that isn't pointless is:

What are your thoughts and opinions on these matters?

Answer: Obviously, I can't have any thoughts or opinions on these girls if I haven't read the comics.

Like I said, this topic is supposed to be for anyone who knows ANY of these characters well. (Princess Sally, Bunny Rabbot, Mina the Mongoose, Hershey the Cat, ... Are there any other girls that I'm forgetting to mention?)

The topic is: What stops each of these girls from being a Mary-Sue? What are their flaws or faults? Be sure to back up your answers with dialogues or actions from these girls.

Last Edited By: Harry Megamix 11/12/2008 12:17 AM. Edited 1 times.

Crazy Cham Lea

[-]

Posts: 1034

(11/12/2008 12:26 AM)

People use the term Mary-Sue far too casually lately.

When Bunnie is found to be a genetically-engineered rabbit hybrid, alien, and vampire in addition to a cyborg with emotion-based colour-changing eyes, the ability to speak six languages fluently, channel the Chaos force, summon her own Piko-Piko hammer, and perform magic better than Merlin Prower on her first attempt while besting Rotor in the realm of science and Rob in terms of archery, all the while with every male (and some females) finding themselves irresistibly drawn to her unique aura and humbly sweet personality before revealing herself as the long-lost Princess Scarlett Primrose Legolas Hikari Starlight, the last of the mysterious Lagomorphia race from the lost city of Atlanlemuria... maybe then there'd be something to talk about.

Toby Barrett

[-]

Posts: 1005

(11/12/2008 12:42 AM)

My Mom Says I'm Cool.

Lea just broke-ed my brain. ;__;

hypershadow77

[-]

Posts: 2314

(11/12/2008 1:08 AM)

INT is crucial for Fighters right?

*quote* The only thing in your reply that isn't pointless is: *quote*

wow, could you be more pompous?

also, lol @ lea's post

------------------
We are fighters
"We are intelligent people who fight from the heart. We are the truest athletes there are. We're what the people write about, cry about, and who they want to see: the pure warrior that comes out and just lays it all out on the line. We do it for pride, for heart and for the love of the sport. We don't make tons of money, yet we give our lives for what we do without regrets of fear."

Psxphile

[-]

Posts: 11341

(11/12/2008 1:10 AM)

Reality whenever...
Gaming forever.

Sega 02: "SONIC TEAM. The Sonic Team development studio was established to execute the wishes of Sega."
Sega 03: "It was intended to enact the business strategy we had created."
Sega 05: "However, it appears to have become dominated by a single, zealous individual."
Sega 04: "Yes it has. We must take it back into our own dominion."
Sega 01: "It is time. We must restore SONIC TEAM and the Sonic series to their proper role."

"Iizuka, you will take responsibility for betraying Sega."

WB

[-]

Posts: 2985

(11/12/2008 1:40 AM)

CNW, TT, STH:
Wetbread VS Eggman!
Round 1: Fight!

TOTAL AGREEMENT

SA Tails

[-]

Posts: 2715

(11/12/2008 1:45 AM)

I R PK J00

Nothing good can come from this...

For a time, Super Sonic Dance Rickroll'd half the typos' rising sun.
DevArt Account	TheIrregulars	Sonic HQ	SonicVerse Team

WB

[-]

Posts: 2986

(11/12/2008 1:55 AM)

CNW, TT, STH:
Wetbread VS Eggman!
Round 1: Fight!

SA Tails wrote:
Nothing good can come from this...

Psxphile

[-]

Posts: 11342

(11/12/2008 2:05 AM)

Reality whenever...
Gaming forever.

Hello, Future Dubs. How's the ol' Insanitarium in the year 2018? I hope they finally got around to spraying for GIANT MUTATED ISOPODS, JESUS LOOK AT THE SIZE OF 'EM GODDAMN THEY'RE RAVAGING THE FOOD SUPPLY.

Sega 02: "SONIC TEAM. The Sonic Team development studio was established to execute the wishes of Sega."
Sega 03: "It was intended to enact the business strategy we had created."
Sega 05: "However, it appears to have become dominated by a single, zealous individual."
Sega 04: "Yes it has. We must take it back into our own dominion."
Sega 01: "It is time. We must restore SONIC TEAM and the Sonic series to their proper role."

"Iizuka, you will take responsibility for betraying Sega."

WB

[-]

Posts: 2988

(11/12/2008 2:08 AM)

CNW, TT, STH:
Wetbread VS Eggman!
Round 1: Fight!

Psxphile wrote:
Hello, Future Dubs. How's the ol' Insanitarium in the year 2018? I hope they finally got around to spraying for GIANT MUTATED ISOPODS, JESUS LOOK AT THE SIZE OF 'EM GODDAMN THEY'RE RAVAGING THE FOOD SUPPLY.

Crimson Darkwolfe

[-]

Posts: 4358

(11/12/2008 7:59 AM)

Permanant Newbie
Lord Hotboxers
Fluffing Toby's Space

Harry Megamix wrote:

Craig Bayfield wrote:

Is this a college assignment you're asking us to write for you?

I'm starting to think all of these Mary-Sue/Gary-Stu topics and the "How do you write a three dimensional character" thing under different usernames feels more like market research fact gathering than discussion. What are your thoughts and opinions on these matters?
Craig, you're not very good at warning us when you're getting off-topic.

The only thing in your reply that isn't pointless is:

What are your thoughts and opinions on these matters?

Answer: Obviously, I can't have any thoughts or opinions on these girls if I haven't read the comics.

Like I said, this topic is supposed to be for anyone who knows ANY of these characters well. (Princess Sally, Bunny Rabbot, Mina the Mongoose, Hershey the Cat, ... Are there any other girls that I'm forgetting to mention?)

The topic is: What stops each of these girls from being a Mary-Sue? What are their flaws or faults? Be sure to back up your answers with dialogues or actions from these girls.

No. Seriously stop this. This isn't the first time somebody has asked you for your input on a matter you've just deigned to throw at us (And never very nicely put either) and this isn't the first time you've just brushed them off and been a complete wanker about it. Message boards are for interaction and you are not interacting. Your'e just throwing questions to which you obviously couldn't care less about the answer to. It's beginning to knack me off.

And I don't get annoyed easily so I can't be the only one.

Are YOU a Gary-Stu?

The Nack Magnum

[-]

Posts: 6

(11/12/2008 10:44 AM)

Crimson Darkwolfe wrote:

No. Seriously stop this. This isn't the first time somebody has asked you for your input on a matter you've just deigned to throw at us (And never very nicely put either) and this isn't the first time you've just brushed them off and been a complete wanker about it. Message boards are for interaction and you are not interacting. Your'e just throwing questions to which you obviously couldn't care less about the answer to. It's beginning to knack me off.

And I don't get annoyed easily so I can't be the only one.

Are YOU a Gary-Stu?

Your reply is not very nicely put either. "Seriously stop this"??... 1) Bad grammar... 2) What makes you think we're going to listen to you?

Interaction is not the only thing message boards are for, and you should know it. What makes you think we care about how "knacked off" you are?

Harry Megamix wrote:

This is for people who know ANY of these characters well.

Princess Sally

Bunny Rabbot

Mina the Mongoose

Hershey the Cat

....Are there any other girls that I'm forgetting to mention?

The topic is: What stops each of these girls from being a Mary-Sue? What are their flaws or faults? Be sure to back up your answers with dialogues or actions from these girls.

Just making sure the main subject stays clear.

Ian Potto

[-]

Posts: 241

(11/12/2008 10:47 AM)

Crazy Cham Lea wrote:
People use the term Mary-Sue far too casually lately.

When Bunnie is found to be a genetically-engineered rabbit hybrid, alien, and vampire in addition to a cyborg with emotion-based colour-changing eyes, the ability to speak six languages fluently, channel the Chaos force, summon her own Piko-Piko hammer, and perform magic better than Merlin Prower on her first attempt while besting Rotor in the realm of science and Rob in terms of archery, all the while with every male (and some females) finding themselves irresistibly drawn to her unique aura and humbly sweet personality before revealing herself as the long-lost Princess Scarlett Primrose Legolas Hikari Starlight, the last of the mysterious Lagomorphia race from the lost city of Atlanlemuria... maybe then there'd be something to talk about.

QUIT SPOILING #200 LEA!!!

The Unofficial Offical Comic's Forum
This Side of Mobius

WB

[-]

Posts: 2990

(11/12/2008 10:58 AM)

CNW, TT, STH:
Wetbread VS Eggman!
Round 1: Fight!

Ian Potto wrote:

Crazy Cham Lea wrote:
People use the term Mary-Sue far too casually lately.

When Bunnie is found to be a genetically-engineered rabbit hybrid, alien, and vampire in addition to a cyborg with emotion-based colour-changing eyes, the ability to speak six languages fluently, channel the Chaos force, summon her own Piko-Piko hammer, and perform magic better than Merlin Prower on her first attempt while besting Rotor in the realm of science and Rob in terms of archery, all the while with every male (and some females) finding themselves irresistibly drawn to her unique aura and humbly sweet personality before revealing herself as the long-lost Princess Scarlett Primrose Legolas Hikari Starlight, the last of the mysterious Lagomorphia race from the lost city of Atlanlemuria... maybe then there'd be something to talk about.

QUIT SPOILING #200 LEA!!!

hypershadow77

[-]

Posts: 2316

(11/12/2008 11:25 AM)

INT is crucial for Fighters right?

Ian Potto wrote:

Crazy Cham Lea wrote:
People use the term Mary-Sue far too casually lately.

When Bunnie is found to be a genetically-engineered rabbit hybrid, alien, and vampire in addition to a cyborg with emotion-based colour-changing eyes, the ability to speak six languages fluently, channel the Chaos force, summon her own Piko-Piko hammer, and perform magic better than Merlin Prower on her first attempt while besting Rotor in the realm of science and Rob in terms of archery, all the while with every male (and some females) finding themselves irresistibly drawn to her unique aura and humbly sweet personality before revealing herself as the long-lost Princess Scarlett Primrose Legolas Hikari Starlight, the last of the mysterious Lagomorphia race from the lost city of Atlanlemuria... maybe then there'd be something to talk about.

QUIT SPOILING #200 LEA!!!

dude i totally saw that plot twist coming. how about something original for once ian? lol jk jk

------------------
We are fighters
"We are intelligent people who fight from the heart. We are the truest athletes there are. We're what the people write about, cry about, and who they want to see: the pure warrior that comes out and just lays it all out on the line. We do it for pride, for heart and for the love of the sport. We don't make tons of money, yet we give our lives for what we do without regrets of fear."

Ian Potto

[-]

Posts: 242

(11/12/2008 11:45 AM)

hypershadow77 wrote:

Ian Potto wrote:

Crazy Cham Lea wrote:
People use the term Mary-Sue far too casually lately.

When Bunnie is found to be a genetically-engineered rabbit hybrid, alien, and vampire in addition to a cyborg with emotion-based colour-changing eyes, the ability to speak six languages fluently, channel the Chaos force, summon her own Piko-Piko hammer, and perform magic better than Merlin Prower on her first attempt while besting Rotor in the realm of science and Rob in terms of archery, all the while with every male (and some females) finding themselves irresistibly drawn to her unique aura and humbly sweet personality before revealing herself as the long-lost Princess Scarlett Primrose Legolas Hikari Starlight, the last of the mysterious Lagomorphia race from the lost city of Atlanlemuria... maybe then there'd be something to talk about.

QUIT SPOILING #200 LEA!!!

dude i totally saw that plot twist coming. how about something original for once ian? lol jk jk

Oh-ho-HO! You want me to bring it? You want it brought?! I got somethin' for ya! I got somethin'!

...

I got nothin'.

The Unofficial Offical Comic's Forum
This Side of Mobius

KaylaTheHedgehog

[-]

Posts: 2918

(11/12/2008 11:48 AM)

Let's do the
Time Warp again!

XD Oh, Dubs, you haven't changed a bit.

That's not very nice spoiling #200, Lea.

*pouts*

My DeviantArt account

We're more than carbon and chemicals
We are the image of the Invisible
We all were lost now we are found
No one can stop us or slow us down
We all are named and we are known
We know that we'll never walk alone
~Thrice

Shadow Hog

[-]

Posts: 13754

(11/12/2008 12:41 PM)

"The miracle
never happen."

The Nack Magnum wrote:
Your reply is not very nicely put either. "Seriously stop this"??... 1) Bad grammar... 2) What makes you think we're going to listen to you?

Interaction is not the only thing message boards are for, and you should know it. What makes you think we care about how "knacked off" you are?

Although I have the sneaking suspicion that you're all the same person (in which case, what "we"?), I'll tell you what makes him think he's going to listen to you: I'M going to make you listen to him. Your posts are very nearly flaming here. Cut it out, now. And don't tell me I'm not being nice, seeing as I already know that - it's my JOB to not be nice.

In short, WE are the moderators here, not you.

As for the girl discussion, it seems like the topic could easily veer too far off into "relationship discussion" territory, which is blatantly against the rules. Not that you've paid much attention to that one, given the other topic...

Crazy Cham Lea

[-]

Posts: 1035

(11/12/2008 12:44 PM)

Oh, drat. I thought Princess Bunnie the Alien Vampire Archer Rabbot-D'Coolette was common knowledge by now.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

The Girls of the Archie Comics : WHAT ARE THEIR FLAWS/FAULTS?

The Girls of the Archie Comics : WHAT ARE THEIR FLAWS/FAULTS?

Quick Reply

The Archie Comics Board - Knothole Village!
	Welcome to Knothole Village! Take a visit here under the shade of the Great Forest and chill for a while. This forum is open for all discussion on absolutely ANYTHING concerning the Archie Sonic Comics, or their cartoon origins in Sonic SatAM and AoStH. SU discussion is also okay here. Consider this place a hub for all fans that wish to discuss, complain, or praise recent goings on. Have fun! :)